We’re taking the classic Reuben to a whole new level, and it all starts with this incredible, homemade Deli-Style Rye Bread! This loaf is soft, savory, and packed with that iconic caraway flavor that makes every bite of a legendary deli sandwich truly unforgettable. It’s the ultimate “Full Scratch” foundation that’s surprisingly easy to bake and far superior to anything you’ll find at the store!
Jump to:
🍯 The Ingredients
A thoughtful combination of natural sweeteners, rich fats, and aromatic accents creates a deeply flavorful dough that bakes into a beautifully tender, golden-crusted masterpiece. Find ingredient notes (including substitutions and variations) below.
📝 Ingredient Notes and Substitutions
- Rye Flour: This is what gives the loaf its signature earthy flavor and rustic texture; we recommend using medium or dark rye flour for the most authentic deli experience, though light rye works well for a milder taste.
- Bread Flour: To ensure the bread has enough structural strength to hold up to a massive, multi-layered Reuben, we use bread flour for its high protein content, but a high-quality all-purpose flour can be used in a pinch.
- Honey and Molasses: This duo provides a subtle, natural sweetness and that deep, dark color characteristic of professional deli bread; if you don’t have molasses, you can substitute it with dark brown sugar for a similar depth of flavor.
- Caraway Seeds: These are responsible for that unmistakable “rye” aroma, but if you prefer a smoother texture, you can lightly crush them before adding them to the dough or use ground caraway instead.
- Melted Butter: Using butter in the dough and as a post-bake finish creates a rich, tender crumb and a soft crust that is much easier to bite through once the sandwich is grilled.
- Active Dry Yeast: This recipe is written for active dry yeast, but if you prefer to use Instant (Rapid Rise) Yeast, you can skip the blooming step and mix it directly into the dry ingredients.
Refer to the recipe card (with video) below for a full list of ingredients and measurements.
📌 Tips and Tricks for Perfect Rye Bread
- Embrace the Stickiness: Rye flour contains “pentosans,” which make the dough feel much tackier than standard white bread dough. Resist the urge to keep adding bread flour; instead, use a bench scraper and lightly floured hands to handle the dough so you don’t end up with a dry, heavy loaf.
- Roll it Tight: When shaping your loaf for the pan, roll it up as tightly as possible, like a jelly roll. This creates a strong internal structure and prevents large air pockets, ensuring your homemade Russian dressing and authentic sauerkraut don’t leak through the middle of your sandwich!
- The Double-Butter Method: Brushing the loaf with an egg wash before baking gives it a beautiful shine, but brushing it with melted butter immediately after it leaves the oven is the secret to a soft, pliable crust.
- Patience is a Virtue: We know it smells incredible, but cutting into rye bread while it’s still warm can cause the interior to become “gummy.” For the best, cleanest sandwich slices, wait at least two hours (or even overnight) before slicing.
- The “Windowpane” Test: To see if you’ve kneaded the dough enough, stretch a small piece of it between your fingers. If it stretches thin enough to see light through it without tearing, the gluten is well-developed, and you’re ready for the first rise!
- Check the Temperature: If you want to be 100% sure your bread is done, use an instant-read thermometer. The center of the loaf should reach between 190°F and 200°F (88°C–93°C). This ensures the rye flour is fully hydrated and the loaf is baked all the way through.
👩🏼🍳 How to Make Rye Bread Dough
- Step 1: In a small bowl, whisk the active dry yeast and honey with the warm water. Let rest for 5 to 10 minutes, until foamy. If it doesn’t foam, you’ll need to get new yeast.
- Step 2: Transfer the yeast mixture to the bowl of your stand mixer. Mix in the molasses, melted butter (2 tbsp), caraway seeds, salt, and then the rye. Mix until combined.
- Step 3: Add the bread flour, 1 cup at a time, until fully combined. The dough will be slightly sticky (don’t add extra flour!). Beat (with the dough attachment) until smooth and elastic.
- Step 4: Place the dough in a greased bowl (or proofing container), cover, and let rise in a warm spot for 60 to 90 minutes, until doubled in size.
Expert Tip: Don’t over-flour!
Rye dough is naturally stickier than wheat dough, but adding too much flour will make your bread dense and heavy. Aim for a “tacky” consistency and use lightly oiled hands or a bench scraper to handle the dough instead of extra flour.
👨🍳 How to Make Deli-Style Rye Sandwich Bread
- Step 1: Punch the dough down, roll it into a tight loaf (jellyroll-style), pinch in the ends, and then place it in a greased 9×5″ loaf pan.
- Step 2: Cover and let rise in a warm spot for another 30 to 45 minutes. Turn your oven to 375°F.
- Step 3: Remove the plastic wrap and gently brush an egg wash (1 egg + 1 tablespoon water) over the top of the loaf.
- Step 4: Bake for 30 to 35 minutes, until golden and the internal temperature reaches 190°F to 200°F.
- Step 5: Brush with melted butter. Let it rest for 5 minutes on a baking rack in the pan.
- Step 6: Remove from the pan and allow the loaf to cool for 2 hours, or overnight.
Expert Tip: Wait to slice!
Cutting into rye bread while it’s still warm can cause the interior to become “gummy” and dense. Letting the loaf cool completely (at least 2 hours) allows the starches to set and the flavor to fully develop for the perfect sandwich slice.
🍽️ How to Serve
- The Ultimate Reuben: Of course, the star of the show! Pile on your 8-day homemade corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and a generous smear of Russian dressing, then grill the sandwich in plenty of butter until the Swiss cheese is perfectly melted and the bread is golden-brown.
- Classic Deli Favorites: This loaf is the ideal companion for thick-cut pastrami, roast turkey, or even a simple ham and Swiss. Serve it with a side of spicy brown mustard and a crisp dill pickle for an authentic deli experience.
- Elevated Breakfast Toast: Toast a thick slice and slather it with high-quality salted butter. The earthy caraway seeds pair beautifully with a fried egg or a schmear of cream cheese and smoked salmon.
- The Perfect Soup Dipper: Because this rye is sturdy and dense, it’s the perfect vessel for dipping into hearty stews or soups. It’s especially delicious alongside a steaming bowl of Slow Cooker Beef Barley or Irish Beef Stew!
- Savory Croutons: If you have any leftovers that have started to get a bit dry, cube them up and toss them with olive oil and garlic salt. Bake until crunchy for the best salad or soup toppers you’ve ever had!
🙋🏽♂️ Frequently Asked Questions
This is perfectly normal because rye flour contains unique starches called pentosans that absorb a lot of water. Instead of adding more flour, try using lightly oiled hands or a bench scraper to handle the dough while kneading and shaping.
While you can certainly make the substitution, the higher protein content in the bread version provides the necessary structure to support the heavy rye flour. Using it ensures your loaf rises high and holds up beautifully when piled with sandwich fillings.
Keep your loaf in an airtight container or a sealed plastic bag at room temperature for up to three days. For longer storage, you can slice the loaf and freeze it for up to three months, simply toasting the slices whenever you’re ready to eat.
Absolutely! While these seeds provide that iconic aroma found in traditional sandwiches, you can leave them out if you prefer a milder flavor profile. The loaf will still have a wonderful earthy taste from the molasses and specialty flour.
This often happens if the dough was over-floured during the kneading process or if it didn’t have enough time to rise. Make sure to let the loaf double in size during both proofing stages to achieve that soft, airy texture.
🍞 Other Classic Bread Recipes
Ready to make a loaf of bread that rivals the best bakery in town? Go for it!
And when you do, be sure to take a photo of it, post it on Instagram, and tag @HowToFeedaLoon and hashtag #HowToFeedaLoon!
The Ultimate Deli-Style Rye Sandwich Bread
Video
Equipment
- Stand mixer see NOTES
- large bowl (or proofing container) for letting the dough rise
- 9"x5" loaf pan
- baking rack
Ingredients
- 1½ cups warm water 110°F/45°C
- 2¼ teaspoon active dry yeast 1 standard packet
- 1 tablespoon honey
- 1 tablespoon molasses
- 2 tablespoon unsalted butter melted, plus more for brushing the baked bread
- 2 tablespoon caraway seeds
- 1½ teaspoon salt
- 1½ cup rye flour medium or dark
- 2¾ cups bread flour (you may not use all of it)
- 1 large egg beaten with 1 tablespoon water
Instructions
- In a small bowl, whisk the yeast and honey into the warm water. Let it sit for 5 to 10 minutes until it becomes foamy. If it doesn't foam, you'll need to get new yeast and start over.1½ cups warm water, 2¼ teaspoon active dry yeast, 1 tablespoon honey
- Add the yeast mixture, along with the molasses, melted butter (2 tbsp), and the rye flour. Mix on medium until combined. Gradually add the bread flour one cup at a time. The dough will be sticky. Add the dough attachment and mix on medium for 6 to 8 minutes. The dough should pull away from the sides but still feel slightly tacky to the touch.1 tablespoon molasses, 2 tablespoon unsalted butter, 2 tablespoon caraway seeds, 1½ teaspoon salt, 1½ cup rye flour, 2¾ cups bread flour
- Place the dough in a lightly greased bowl or container (with a lid). Cover and let rise in a warm spot for 60 to 90 minutes, until doubled in size.
- Gently punch down the dough and turn it onto a lightly floured surface. Pat or roll the dough into a rectangle roughly 8 inches wide and 12 inches long. Starting from the short (8-inch) side, roll the dough up tightly like a jelly roll. Pinch the seam shut with your fingers and tuck the ends under slightly.
- Place the log, seam-side down, into a greased 9"x5" loaf pan. Cover lightly with plastic wrap or a light towel. Place in the same warm spot and let rise for another 30 to 45 minutes. The dough should rise about 1 to 2 inches above the rim of the pan.
- Preheat your oven to 375°F.
- Gently brush the top of the loaf with the egg wash (1 beaten egg with 1 tablespoon water). Be gentle and try not to deflate the loaf; it's okay if it deflates a little.1 large egg
- Bake for 30 to 35 minutes. The crust should be a deep golden brown, and the internal temperature should reach 190 to 200°F.
- Immediately after taking the loaf out of the oven, brush the top with 2 tablespoon of melted butter. Let the bread rest in the pan for 5 minutes, and then invert the pan and let it cool on a baking rack for at least 2 hours before slicing.
- The bread can be stored in an air-tight container or bag for 4 to 6 days.
Notes
- Check Your Yeast: Always ensure your yeast hasn’t expired before starting. When blooming the yeast, if the mixture doesn’t become foamy and bubbly within 5–10 minutes, the yeast is likely inactive. You will need to start over with a fresh packet to ensure your bread rises properly!
- Flour Control: Start with 2 ½ cups of bread flour and add the remaining amount only as needed. You may not use the full 2¾ cups, depending on the humidity and the specific brand of flour you are using.
- Don’t Over-Flour! Rye dough is naturally stickier than wheat dough. Resist the urge to add extra flour just to make it easier to handle; the dough should remain tacky to ensure a soft, airy crumb rather than a dense, heavy loaf.
- Cooling is Key: For the best sandwich slices, allow the loaf to cool completely on a wire rack for at least 2 hours before slicing. Cutting into it while warm can cause the interior to become gummy.
- Storage: Store in an airtight bag at room temperature for up to 3 to 4 days, or slice and freeze for up to 3 months.
Kevin Carson says
Gonna make this my St. Paddy’s Day reuben bread!
Wesley says
DELICIOUS! Nothing better than homemade bread! This rye bread was just the right amount of rye-ness, if you know what I mean. Just give me some butter and I’m good!
Kris Longwell says
Woo hoo! Homemade bread is the BEST!!